Subaru Sports Car With Automatic Transmission: Is It Worth It?

Hey guys! Thinking about getting a Subaru sports car but want the ease of an automatic transmission? You're not alone! Many car enthusiasts find themselves at this crossroads. Let's dive deep into the world of Subaru sports cars with automatic transmissions, exploring the pros, cons, and whether it's the right choice for you.

The Allure of Subaru Sports Cars

Subaru sports cars, like the BRZ and the WRX, have carved out a special place in the hearts of driving enthusiasts. These cars are known for their engaging handling, punchy engines, and rally-inspired heritage. Their appeal lies in the promise of a fun and connected driving experience. The BRZ, with its rear-wheel-drive configuration, offers a classic sports car feel, while the WRX, boasting all-wheel drive, provides incredible grip and all-weather capability. When you think of Subaru, you probably think of their dedication to performance and reliability. Their vehicles are built to last and handle some serious driving. Now, adding an automatic transmission into the mix... well, that's what we're here to discuss! Many drivers are hesitant to switch from manual to automatic. Some are against it. But some find that they prefer the ease of an automatic. So, let's get to it!

Automatic Transmissions: Convenience vs. Purity

Traditionally, sports cars have been associated with manual transmissions. The ability to row through the gears, perfectly matching revs, and feeling the direct connection to the engine has been seen as an integral part of the sports car experience. However, automatic transmissions have come a long way in recent years. Modern automatics, especially those found in performance cars, offer lightning-fast shifts, intelligent programming, and even paddle shifters for manual control. The main advantage is convenience. In heavy traffic or during long commutes, an automatic transmission can be a godsend, reducing driver fatigue and making the overall driving experience more relaxed. However, some purists argue that an automatic transmission dulls the connection between the driver and the car, diminishing the overall engagement and fun factor. They feel that the control and precision offered by a manual transmission are essential for truly experiencing the full potential of a sports car. At the end of the day, it boils down to preference. There's no objectively better choice, just what you prefer as a driver.

Subaru's Automatic Offerings: A Closer Look

So, how do Subaru's automatic transmissions stack up in their sports cars? Let's take a closer look at the BRZ and WRX.

Subaru BRZ Automatic

The Subaru BRZ, known for its balanced handling and playful nature, is available with an automatic transmission. The automatic BRZ offers a slightly different driving experience compared to the manual version. The shifts are smooth and quick, and the transmission does a decent job of anticipating your needs. However, some drivers may find that the automatic BRZ lacks the directness and engagement of the manual. The automatic transmission can sometimes feel a bit hesitant to downshift, especially when you're trying to extract maximum performance from the engine. Despite this, the automatic BRZ remains a fun and capable sports car, especially for those who prioritize convenience and ease of use. The automatic version is also more accessible to a wider range of drivers, including those who may not be comfortable with a manual transmission. If you're looking for a pure, unadulterated sports car experience, the manual BRZ might be the better choice. But if you value convenience and ease of driving, the automatic BRZ is definitely worth considering. You should test drive both and see how you feel about them!

Subaru WRX Automatic

The Subaru WRX, with its turbocharged engine and all-wheel-drive system, is a performance icon. The WRX is also available with an automatic transmission, although it's a CVT (Continuously Variable Transmission) rather than a traditional automatic. The CVT in the WRX has been a subject of debate among enthusiasts. On one hand, it offers smooth and seamless acceleration, and it can help to improve fuel economy. On the other hand, some drivers find that the CVT lacks the responsiveness and engagement of a traditional automatic or manual transmission. The CVT can sometimes feel a bit disconnected from the engine, and it can produce a droning sound under hard acceleration. However, Subaru has made improvements to the CVT in recent years, adding simulated gear steps to make it feel more like a traditional automatic. Despite its quirks, the CVT in the WRX can be surprisingly effective, especially in everyday driving situations. The all-wheel-drive system provides incredible traction and stability, making the WRX a formidable performer in all kinds of weather. If you're looking for a practical and capable performance car with all-weather capability, the automatic WRX is definitely worth considering. However, if you're a die-hard enthusiast who demands the ultimate in driving engagement, the manual WRX might be a better fit. It's really up to you and what kind of driving you like to do!

Performance and Driving Dynamics

When comparing the automatic and manual versions of Subaru sports cars, there are some key differences in performance and driving dynamics.

• Acceleration: In general, the manual versions tend to be slightly quicker in terms of acceleration. The direct connection between the engine and the wheels allows for more precise control over the power delivery, resulting in faster off-the-line acceleration and quicker passing times. However, modern automatics with launch control can sometimes match or even surpass the acceleration of manual cars, especially in the hands of less experienced drivers.
• Handling: The handling characteristics of the automatic and manual versions are generally similar. However, the manual versions may offer a slightly more engaging and connected feel due to the greater level of control over the drivetrain. The ability to precisely select gears and control the engine speed can enhance the overall driving experience, especially on twisty roads.
• Fuel Economy: The fuel economy of the automatic and manual versions can vary depending on the specific model and driving conditions. In some cases, the automatic versions may offer slightly better fuel economy due to the optimized shift patterns and the ability to keep the engine in its most efficient operating range. However, the manual versions can also achieve excellent fuel economy with careful driving techniques.

The Verdict: Is an Automatic Subaru Sports Car Right for You?

So, is a Subaru sports car with an automatic transmission the right choice for you? It depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you prioritize convenience, ease of use, and all-weather capability, an automatic Subaru sports car can be a great option. The automatic transmissions in the BRZ and WRX offer smooth shifts, intelligent programming, and decent performance. However, if you're a purist who values the ultimate in driving engagement and control, the manual versions might be a better fit. The manual transmissions offer a more direct connection to the car, allowing you to fully exploit the engine's power and the car's handling capabilities.

Ultimately, the best way to decide is to test drive both the automatic and manual versions of the BRZ and WRX. See which one feels more comfortable and engaging to you. Consider your daily driving needs, your personal preferences, and your budget. With careful consideration, you can find the perfect Subaru sports car to suit your lifestyle. Whether you opt for the convenience of an automatic or the engagement of a manual, you're sure to enjoy the unique driving experience that Subaru sports cars have to offer. At the end of the day, the car is for you, so make sure it's a car that you like!